The comment conundrum

It’s true that this blog never really landed a lot of comments. 5-10 was pretty average, but lately I’ve noticed a big change. Most posts don’t have a single comment, while others will get 1 or two (hello Marsha Drews!).

This is not a cry for more comments (though that would be nice), it’s just a commentary on the state of comments.

I think comments over all may have dropped off and I think I know why. I know this because my personal comment frequency has dropped dramatically and I blame it all on the iPhone.

I do most of my blog reading now from my iPhone using my reader while I’m getting the kids to sleep at night. It’s such a hassle to comment using my iPhone that it takes great motivation or something I must say before I will actually do it.

But I think I have a solution. You know how easy it is to comment on Facebook or Instagram on your phone. No problem, right? There’s that text box right below just waiting for you. But in a reader, you have to click over to the blog, find the leave a comment place, sometimes log in or even type a (heaven forbid ) catchpa (is that the right word for those crazy letters I can’t tell apart?) phrase. To say that it is not easy to comment on a blog is putting it mildly. It can be a loop of interconnecting web pages that you can get lost in for several minutes (and then your comment may not even post!)

Here’s my solution: a comment box like on Facebook below every post you read in your reader. The reader is just so darn convenient, those of us who use it are not going back to the old-fashioned way of browsing blogs one by one, but the reader needs to catch up to the rest of the world. Add a comment box that we can stay logged into. Logged in, just like we are when we are in our reader. So easy.

I’ve designed a little snapshot of what it could look like using Meredith’s blog. What a simpler world it would be.

So Google, you up for that?

What do you say? Would you comment more if it were easier to do directly from your reader?

 

  • http://profiles.google.com/jennipearl Jenni Trietsch

    YES! I would absolutely comment more if it was easier from reader. Through the day when I’m reading blogs at work, it isn’t really that much extra work to click over. But early morning or late nights when I’m reading on my iPhone, yes, it is too much effort.

  • Lol_ly_gag

    Good ol’ Marsha. :)

  • Meredith@Lifeat7000Feet

    Completely agree that my reader needs this feature! I always think that I want to go back and comment on certain blogs but I rarely do. L-A-M-E and L-A-Z-Y. I’ll own every bit of my sloth. :)

  • http://athomeonthelastfrontier.blogspot.com Melissa

    That would be much easier for commenting purposes. Great idea!

  • Mamaduso

    Yes I would. That is a brilliant idea. Sometimes if I go to a blog from fb I will go back to fb and leave a comment under the link. Actually anymore going from fb links is how read blogs. I totally forget about my blog reader. Sand I must have several hundred blog posts that I will never get to Mehta I hate about google reader is that I delete blogs and it will add them back after a period of time. Posting from my iPad is so much easier!

  • eclecticwhatnot

    Oooh, yes. Marsha is the best commenter. Hands down!

  • Sharon @ HIking Toward Home

    Yes. I notice the same problem. I got into a habit of reading blogs in my reader. I’m really not liking it too much. Because the other thing is, that you didn’t mention about NOT clicking over… I miss going to the actual space of the blog. Bloggers pour themselves into (and their money) redesigning an amazing new blog design and so many NEVER SEE IT!! Because many either subscribe through email or readers it becomes a hassle to leave that comment even if it is only a few sparse words (unlike the epic I just left you).
    AS a blogger, I would rather people come to my actual space and they would read and comment more… of course I haven’t put up a new post in *a very long time* (It’s not like I have zillions of followers, I’ve probably lost those I did have due to lack of posting and also nixing GFC.)
    Yes, I agree, the Google geeks need to come up with a way of commenting through a reader. (Sorry I haven’t been by in a long while… lack of reading as well as posting :-( )

  • http://www.facebook.com/suzannecatesparker Suzanne Cates Parker

    Considering I was reading you in a reader, had to click through and now have hoop jump, yes, I would comment more. C’mon, google! (and it would be nice if you gave Melissa a kickback)

  • Sissy

    I’m commenting to let you know we finally got a baby! So you’ll actually need to come over to my blog and see my boy and comment using an actual computer. LOL. Come and meet Jackson.

  • http://afamiliarpath.com/ Melissa Stover

    if only.

  • http://afamiliarpath.com/ Melissa Stover

    me too. i hate commenting from my phone.

  • http://afamiliarpath.com/ Melissa Stover

    isn’t she the best?

  • http://afamiliarpath.com/ Melissa Stover

    i completely understand. glad to see you today!

  • http://afamiliarpath.com/ Melissa Stover

    give me a link. i forgot where your site is.

  • http://www.facebook.com/laura.sims.773 Laura Sims

    This is the reason I love when people link to their post through FB and I can comment on the posts there. Much easier!

  • dawnMHSH

    Since I’m leaving this from my iPhone (score!) what reader do you use on yours?

  • Stacy Averette

    I’m fairly new to blogging and using an iPhone. I do subscribe to
    several of my favorite blogs but I almost always go to the actual blog
    space on my computer. If I don’t have access to my computer I will read
    the post in my reader but you’re right Melissa…. I don’t comment that
    way. Seeing the blog on a computer screen is inspirational and visually
    satisfying. Only using my reader would mean I would miss why I regularly
    visit some blogs in the first place. Maybe I’m “behind the times” in
    this. Many of my friends are always glued to their iPhone so I think
    you’re right in your conclusion. I always learn something when I come to
    A Familiar Path. It’s at the top of my bookmarks list. Thanks!

  • http://www.partofthemiracles.blogspot.com/ Beth

    GREAT idea! love it. Maybe google will sit up and pay attention!